Logo for Pennsylvania Evidence Resource Center
Start of content
Together, we'realways learning.

Thoughtfully applying evidence to the work of schools is both an art and a science. Explore the topics below to brush up on research concepts, consider questions of quality, and strengthen your skills in evidence-based decision making.

Explore by topic:

Our Review Process

The ERC has a detailed and specific process for reviewing evidence in support of educational strategies. We use nationally recognized standards, document our findings, and consult with research organizations so we can suggest ESSA tiers for outcomes studied. Take a look at our protocols and process:

Standards

The ESSA tiers of evidence are closely aligned to the standards of the What Works Clearinghouse (WWC), an investment of the Institute of Education Sciences (IES) within the U.S. Department of Education. In fact, outcomes only qualify for ESSA tiers 1 and 2 if they meet WWC standards (with, or without reservations, respectively). The WWC standards are updated periodically and can be browsed by the public on the IES website:

To stay closely aligned to the non-regulatory guidance for ESSA, the ERC relies on evidence reviews against the standards of the WWC to assign suggested ESSA tiers and populate our clearinghouse. Reviews of research studies against these standards may be conducted by What Works Clearinghouse itself, or by other professional research organizations. Per our research process, those organizations help determine if the study meets WWC standards, and also determine the ESSA tiers of the study outcomes.

To use resources efficiently, if another professional, independent research organization has assigned a WWC rating and an ESSA tier to an outcome for an educational strategy, the ERC may publish that rating without conducting our own separate review.

More on this topic

  • The What Works Clearinghouse (WWC) produces practice guides that summarize evidence and make recommendations for improving outcomes in specific topic areas.Navigating WWC Practice Guides

  • Are you interested in understanding the WWC review process? You can become a certified reviewer and learn how the WWC determines its evidence ratings.WWC Group Design Standards Online Training

Looking for something else?

Contact us with questions you have about a specific topic.

Contact Us
Back to topics